History: Get Me Rewrite!

Feb 19 2014

Maureen Dowd – The New York Times

I found myself sitting on a bar stool last winter next to Robert Caro at an Irish wake in Times Square for my irreplaceable Times colleague Frank Prial.

I had an overpowering urge to grab Caro?s arm and shake him. For the love of Pete, I wanted to yelp at the 78-year-old historian who has spent 38 years chronicling Lyndon Johnson in more than 3,388 pages, was he ever going to get to Vietnam?

But the shy, bespectacled writer picking at his hors d?oeuvres did not look like the sort of man who could be rushed.

As Adam Nagourney wrote in The Times on Sunday, Luci Baines Johnson and other members of L.B.J.?s shrinking circle are pushing to broaden the lens on the president?s legacy so that it is not merely viewed ?through the prism of a failed war.?

They are using the 50th anniversary of Johnson?s more impressive domestic policies ? including the Civil Rights Act, the Clean Air Act and Medicare ? to yank the focus away from ?the agony of Vietnam? and ?his cross,? as his daughter calls it.

?Nobody wanted that war less than Lyndon Johnson,? the 66-year-old Luci said, adding that he tried mightily to get out.

Maybe ratcheting up the war with more than 500,000 troops and sending so many young Americans to their deaths halfway around the world based on chest-thumping advice and a na?ve theory of democratic dominoes was a deterrent to getting out.

In the new Broadway play with Bryan Cranston as L.B.J., ?All The Way,? by Robert Schenkkan, there?s a scene where Robert McNamara pushes Johnson to order ?retaliatory? airstrikes after the Potemkin Gulf of Tonkin. Hubert Humphrey tries to slow them down, noting that they should not strike back ?for an attack which may or may not have happened,? but Johnson, prodded by McNamara, frets about how Barry Goldwater would slam him if he went ?soft on the military.?

Johnson was determined not to be seen as weak, not to ?cut and run? ? the same phrase later used by W. about Iraq when he was determined not to be seen as a wimp and began sending so many young Americans to their deaths halfway around the world based on chest-thumping advice and a na?ve theory of democratic dominoes.

Asked by a reporter about Iraq recently, W.?s eyes flashed and he replied, ?I am not happy.?

He shouldn?t be. Afghanistan, which he abandoned to pursue a phony ?retaliatory? war in Iraq, is crumbling despite all the money, muscle and blood we have poured into it, with our runaway fruitcake puppet Hamid Karzai fiddling while the Taliban burns, vowing to run America out just as they did the Russians and waging vicious attacks on women.

In corrupt and violent Iraq, women are getting detained illegally and tortured. The country is awash in a blood-dimmed tide, with nearly 9,000 killed last year and almost 1,000 killed last month, as Al Qaeda and another jihadist group fight for supremacy. In Falluja, the city where nearly 100 American soldiers died in the fiercest fighting of the war, the black insurgent flag now flies over buildings.

With the help of his own personal librarian, Laura, W. has been trying to reframe his legacy to take the focus off his botched wars, just like L.B.J.?s family. His presidential library highlights his work on AIDS in Africa, belatedly tapering the roles of his sulfurous regents, Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld.

With Laura at his side, W. spent a long time chatting with reporters on the way to Nelson Mandela?s funeral, putting his own spin on his presidency.

A version of this op-ed appears in print on February 19, 2014, on page A19 of the New York edition with the headline: History: Get Me Rewrite!.

site admin